Scary Story Slumber Party

Jeep (segment "Valentine's Prey")

Evan (segment "Bashed") (as Russ A. Bryan)

Erin (segment "The Pledge")

Erin (segment "Noise Complaint")

Jack Bradford (segment "The Deadly Hook")

Bar Girl 4 (segment "UnLucky Night")

Danielle (segment "The Slumber Party")

Becca (segment "Event Invitation")

Brad (segment "UnLucky Night")

Holly (segment "The Dare")

Rachel (segment "UnLucky Night")

Hilary (segment "The Pledge")

Party Boy (segment "Noise Complaint")

Melissa (segment "The Pledge")

Matt (segment: "Backstabber")

Aaron (segment "Noise Complaint")

Tommy (segment Valentine's Prey")

Steven (segment "Noise Complaint") / Jeff (segment "Imaginary Fiend")

Karissa (segment: "Slumber Party"), Courtney (segment: "The Pledge") / Tiffany (segment: "Noise Complaint")

Lindy (segment "Valentine's Prey") / Kate (Segment: "The Pledge")

Brittney (segment "Slumber Party / Grave Misfortune") / Megan (segment "Noise Complaint") / Kristen (segment "Imaginary Fiend") (as Brittney M. Scalf)

Amy (segment: "Backstabber") / Emma (segment: "Noise Complaint")

Party Girl (segment "Noise Complaint")

Claire (segment: "Noise Complaint") / Jaclyn (segment: "Imaginary Fiend")

Jenna (segment "The Pledge")

Kristen (segment "Bashed")